Talking to Insurers

An Adjuster Asked to Record You. Here's How to Handle It

The phone tends to ring a day or two after the wreck, with a friendly voice who just needs to get your side on tape. Before you say yes, it helps to know what that recording is for.

Updated November 17, 2026 · General information, not legal advice

Person on a phone call taking notes beside an insurance claim form
  • If the caller is from the other driver's insurer, you generally do not have to give a recorded statement.
  • Your own insurer is another story, since your policy probably obligates you to cooperate.
  • You can be polite, give basic facts and still say no to the recording.

Adjusters are usually pleasant, and many are decent people doing a job. But it helps to remember what that job is. An adjuster for the other driver's insurance company is paid to resolve the claim for as little as fairly possible. A recorded statement is a tool for that.

First, figure out who is calling

Ask the caller three things before you say anything about the crash:

  1. What is your name and phone number?
  2. What company do you work for?
  3. Whose insurance company is that, mine or the other driver's?

Write the answers down. Those three questions decide most of what comes next.

If it is the other driver's company

You have no contract with that company, so as a rule nothing obligates you to be recorded by it. You can still open a claim with it and share basic facts. A recording can be used later to:

  • lock you into details you were not sure about, like speed or distance,
  • suggest you were partly to blame, which in Texas can reduce what you recover,
  • point to "I'm okay" or "I'm fine" said out of habit, and
  • catch small differences between what you say now and later.

None of that means you did anything wrong. Memory after a crash is patchy, and you may not yet know how badly you were hurt.

If it is your own company

Your own policy likely includes a duty to cooperate, which can mean giving a statement when you claim PIP, collision or uninsured motorist benefits. A flat refusal could put that coverage at risk. Even so, you are free to:

  • ask to schedule the call for a time when you are ready,
  • keep your answers to what you know firsthand, and
  • talk with an attorney first if you have been hurt.

Our PIP guide explains how claims with your own company work.

A simple script for the call

You do not need to be rude. You can say something like:

"I'm still getting medical care, and I'm not comfortable giving a recorded statement right now. I'm happy to confirm who I am, how to reach me, and when and where the wreck happened. Please send any other questions in writing."

That keeps the claim moving without handing over a recording.

If you decide to go ahead

Some people decide to give a statement anyway, especially for a small property damage claim. If you do:

  • Have your notes, photos and the report number in front of you.
  • Answer only the question asked, then stop.
  • Do not guess. "I don't know" and "I'm not sure" are honest answers.
  • Do not describe your injuries as minor or say you are fine. Say you are still being treated.
  • Do not agree to discuss your medical history beyond this crash.
  • Request that they send you the recording afterward.

Right after any adjuster call

Whether you gave a statement or not, take five minutes once you hang up and write a few lines:

  1. When the call happened.
  2. The adjuster's name, company, phone number and claim number.
  3. What they asked for and what you agreed to send.
  4. Anything they said about fault, coverage or payment.

Keep those notes with your crash photos and bills. If a dispute comes up months later, a dated note written the same day is far more reliable than memory. If the adjuster promised something by phone, send a short email repeating it so there is a written trail.

Other things they may ask for

Adjusters may also send a blanket medical authorization that lets them pull years of records unrelated to the crash. You can generally decline it and provide records tied to this wreck instead. Be careful with early checks or releases, too. Cashing a check marked as a final settlement, or signing a release, can end your claim. Our insurance claims guide goes over these traps.

Handing off the phone calls

Once you hire an attorney, the adjuster generally has to deal with that attorney instead of you. For many people that is the biggest relief of the whole process. Before you agree to that recording, ring (903) 357-5775 or use the case review page to reach a Texas injury lawyer who is independent of this site.

Sources

Questions & answers

Do I have to give the other driver's insurance a recorded statement in Texas?

Usually not. You never signed anything with that company. You can share basic facts and still decline to be recorded.

Can I refuse a recorded statement to my own insurance company?

Your policy likely requires you to cooperate, which can include a statement. You can usually ask to schedule it and talk with an attorney first.

What if I already gave a recorded statement?

That is common and does not end your claim. Write down what you remember saying, request the recording itself and avoid further recorded calls until you get advice.

Free · no obligation

Talk to a Texoma injury attorney's office

Tell us what happened and someone will call you back — usually the same day. Prefer to call? (903) 357-5775.

Get a free callback

Free · private · about a minute

What happened?
Were you hurt?
Have a lawyer already?

or call (903) 357-5775

CallFree callback